2024s Game of the Year Contenders Who Will Snag the Coveted Title at the Game Awards

The Game Awards 2024 are just around the corner, and it’s time to crown the Game of the Year (GOTY). As this prestigious event celebrates its tenth anniversary, the competition is fiercer than ever. Here’s our rundown of the top contenders with an in-depth look at each game vying for the title.

Beyond these six frontrunners, there are some other games that might shake up the predictions. Dragon’s Dogma 2 boasts an immersive open world and a Metascore of 86, though its system-focused gameplay has divided opinions. STALKER 2: Heart of Chornobyl could make a significant emotional impact given its development context in Ukraine. And don’t sleep on Metaphor: ReFantazio by Atlus and The Plucky Squire, both of which should be on your radar.

Want to dive deeper into 2024’s GOTY potentials? Check out our full analysis of Astro Bot or explore the hype behind Black Myth: Wukong and why everyone’s talking about it.

Top 6 Contenders for Game of the Year 2024

1. Final Fantasy 7 Rebirth – The Unshakeable?

Why it might win: With a Metascore surpassing 90, this second installment of the Final Fantasy 7 remake is already hailed as a masterpiece. Square Enix has crafted an even more ambitious sequel with an engrossing story, stunning visuals, and exceptional performances. Moreover, the strong backing from the PlayStation community could be a decisive factor. Having snagged the “Most Anticipated Game” award in 2023, its chances are bolstered.

Weaknesses: Despite critical acclaim, sales have fallen short of expectations, which might impact votes. Some critics aren’t entirely unanimous about its overall quality, despite its high Metascore.

2. Astro Bot – The Surprising Contender

Why it might win: With a Metascore of 94, Astro Bot is the highest-rated game of the year. Developed by Team Asobi, this platformer is a technical marvel featuring innovative gameplay mechanics that fully exploit the PS5’s capabilities. In terms of playability, Astro Bot offers an immersive and fun experience, earning universal praise from critics.

Weaknesses: Games in the “Family” category, where Astro Bot is often placed, rarely clinch the Game of the Year award. Its relatively simple narrative might cost it points compared to more content-rich titles.

3. The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom – A Nintendo Giant

Why it might win: Although not yet released, Echoes of Wisdom is set to revolutionize the Zelda franchise once again, following in the footsteps of the GOTY-winning Breath of the Wild. Known for its unmatched creativity, Nintendo has crafted a new adventure combining exploration and puzzles that should captivate fans. Critics are already anticipating an exceptional reception upon release.

Weaknesses: Historically, Nintendo has struggled to win the top prize at the Game Awards, except for Breath of the Wild. The “all-ages” visual style of Echoes of Wisdom could be a disadvantage compared to more mature or graphically sophisticated titles.

4. Animal Well – The Indie Dark Horse

Why it might win: Animal Well, an adventure-puzzle game with a Metascore of 91, has the most potential among indie contenders this year. Its unique aesthetic, contemplative gameplay, and mysterious narrative have won critical acclaim. Additionally, the backing of Bigmode, the publishing arm of popular YouTuber Dunkey, ensures it gains attention.

Weaknesses: Despite rave reviews, indie games traditionally face challenges in clinching the Game of the Year title. Its complexity and depth might not appeal to a broader audience.

5. Black Myth: Wukong – The Chinese Blockbuster

Why it might win: Black Myth: Wukong is a spectacular action-adventure game inspired by Chinese mythology, featuring breathtaking visuals. Its impressive gameplay and immersive ambiance have won over a large audience, particularly in China, with fans being extremely vocal on social media. Despite a Metascore of 81, the buzz around the game remains massive.

Weaknesses: At 81 on Metacritic, it’s the lowest-scoring game among the contenders, which could be a problem against titles all scoring above 90. Additionally, its success being primarily localized in China might struggle to sway an international jury.

6. Like a Dragon: Infinite Wealth – The Unexpected Favorite

Why it might win: Once considered a niche series, the Like a Dragon (formerly Yakuza) franchise has seen its popularity skyrocket in recent years. Infinite Wealth, with a Metascore of 89, has charmed critics with its blend of captivating storytelling, quirky humor, and immersive gameplay. The upcoming television series could provide additional spotlight.

Weaknesses: Its biggest challenge is its early January release, which might make it forgettable as voting approaches. Despite having its dedicated fanbase, it remains relatively less accessible compared to other competing games.